When I was selecting a good bed frame to place my mattress on, I was surprised by the many types of frames to choose from! After doing much research and deliberation, I ended up with just two contenders: The platform bed and box spring. They each had their own unique advantages and disadvantages that made them a great choice. However, I only had to pick one!
So I did the research and decided to go for the one I felt like I could utilize for the long-term. If you’re confused with what to select, then I give you the much-needed information on the platform bed vs box spring: which one should you choose?
What is A Platform Bed
A platform bed is one of the bed frames growing in popularity today, known for its variety of designs to choose from.
In short, the platform bed is made of a simple frame, using various materials which can support any type of mattress without needing the box spring. Usually, these bed frames are either flat, lower-profile or with a slatted support surface which is best for contemporary interior designs.
The platform bed has a flat and solid surface, with slats that are used to support a mattress. Some even include storage drawers to save on space in the room!
Advantages and Disadvantages of A Platform Bed
So, what does the platform bed have to offer? Here are its pros and cons:
1. Style – A platform bed has a clean and modern look that works well if you’re into a contemporary design. If you’re one who likes to focus on both comfort and aesthetics, this is a good benefit.
2. Compatibility – The platform bed is quite durable and sturdy, providing support for any kind of mattresses, especially those of memory foam or latex! It also provides more stability, which is great for those who are on the heavy side or usually move around while sleeping.
3. Storage – Like mentioned, platform beds come with storage drawers, which can save on space and provide more organization in the room.
1. Low on the Ground – While being low on the ground is advantageous for those who have trouble getting in a higher-elevated bed, it may pose difficulty for those with back or knee problems. It’ll take time getting used to!
2. May Be Too Firm for Side Sleepers – The mattress will sit directly on top of the solid slats or platform, which will have the bed feel firmer. The extra firmness isn’t the best for side or stomach sleepers, as the pressure will make you feel uncomfortable.
3. Moving It Around – If you move around a lot, then this may be a problem because it either uses a lot of slats or one flat board which is bigger than your mattress. This will be a bit difficult to move!
What is A Box Spring?
As for the box spring, these are actually the classic or traditional bed frames we know. Typically, these are made of a wooden frame (which is the box), designed to absorb and distribute the weight on your mattress. Sometimes, there are added steel reinforcements to provide more strength and support, depending on your mattress’ weight.
The frame has a series of heavy gauge wire coils (or it also uses a grid) attached to it, which is the support system. These are then covered with a skid-resistant fabric, then the mattress is placed
There are many types of box springs depending on the strength and support you need.
Advantages and Disadvantages of A Box Spring
A box spring is an affordable option, but what else can it give you? Here are its pros and cons:
1. Price – Compared to a platform bed, the box spring comes at a much cheaper price and is best for those on a budget. However, you’ll need to purchase more parts, such as the frame and rails.
2. Absorbs Shock – A box spring helps your innerspring mattress absorb the shock if you ever jump or move around (or if you are a heavier sleeper). That way, it lengthens the mattress’ lifespan compared to placing it on the floor.
3. Added Elevation – The most common benefit of these bed frames is that it raises your bed, making it pleasing to the eye and better for those with a bad back/knees. Plus, it prevents small pets and insects from going on your bed.
1. Only For Innersprings – Because a box spring isn’t as strong as a platform bed, it’s best suited for innerspring mattresses only. It doesn’t have the versatility compared to other bed frames.
2. Loses Support – Like mentioned, the box spring isn’t as supportive as the platform bed. Because of this, it would lose support over time, requiring replacement or the necessity to turn it over regularly.
3. No Storage Space – There is little to no room to add your items under the bed for added storage. This may not be a good choice for those who are looking for ways to save up on more space in the room!
The Differences Between Both Frames
Now that you’re familiar with what the platform bed and box spring has to offer, what are the main differences that make them unique? Here are the following features to consider:
1. Compatible Mattresses
For starters, a platform bed is best suited for memory foam or natural latex mattresses, as well as innersprings. This is because it has the sturdiness and adequate air circulation you need for better comfort.
For a box spring, it’s best suited solely for innersprings, as it’s designed to support those types of mattresses.
2. Sturdiness and Durability
The platform bed is more durable compared to the box spring, which is why there are more mattresses that are compatible with this type of bed frame. The box spring is less durable and is only designed to support the innerspring, not as sturdy compared to other types of foundations.
3. Your Budget Range
While the box spring isn’t as sturdy as the platform bed, it’s definitely the cheapest option. Platform beds are a bit on the pricier side, made for those who have the budget. If not, then a box spring will do adequately, provided that you use an innerspring mattress.
4. Personal Style and Space-Saving Properties
A platform bed is known for its space-saving properties, though you can also use a box spring to place your items underneath the frame. As for personal style, though, the platform bed will have to win here as it really allows your wanted design to come through in the entire bedroom.
Platform Bed vs Box Spring: Which One Should You Choose?
They each have their major differences and with unique characteristics that make them advantageous, depending on your bedroom and what kind of sleeper you are. However, which is the better of the two?
Personally, I’m a bigger fan of the platform bed, as it has storage capacities that help me save up on space in my room. However, this is subjective to your needs and wants. What I may prefer may be different from the next sleeper.
If you want something that offers a firmer surface that still offers the softness you need on a firm mattress than a box spring is for you. But if you want something with a simplistic, contemporary design that’s lower to the ground (for those having trouble with their knees), then the platform bed is most suitable.
I advise you to look into the pros and cons of each again, looking into the different features to get the one that you need most.
Wrapping It Up
It’s important to select a bed frame suitable for you so you are assured a better night’s sleep. While the platform bed and box spring have significant differences, there is no better one suitable for everyone. Through learning about its unique features, as well as its pros and cons, you’ll be able to find out which one is best suited for you.
Hopefully, this article on the platform bed vs box spring: “which one should you choose?” answered your question. So don’t wait any longer and search for the suitable frames for you!
If you have any questions or want to share your tips and experiences when using any of these bed frames, then comment below. Your thoughts are much appreciated.